A Straight Dope Classic from Cecil's Storehouse of Human Knowledge

Are there better ways out of a burning building than taking the stairs?

October 28, 2016

Dear Cecil:

We’re told not to use the elevators if there’s a fire. But how are people expected to evacuate from skyscrapers? Does everyone really just take the stairs? I’m disabled, and I wouldn’t want someone risking their life carrying me down so many flights. Couldn’t they connect the tall buildings like hospitals do, so you could evacuate horizontally?

Cecil replies:

One World Trade Center, nicknamed the Freedom Tower, reaches 94 stories into the sky. That’s 16 floors fewer than the ill-fated skyscrapers that once occupied the same site, but still, clambering down its 2,226 steps from top to bottom would be a schlep under ordinary circumstances, let alone with lives at stake. You’re not the first to suspect there must be a better way to clear tall buildings during a calamity than trooping every occupant down the staircases. In the 15 years since the towers fell, engineers have hunkered down to rethink building-safety design and emergency evacuation procedures.

Conducting folks out of fiery high-rises through enclosed overhead walkways doesn’t seem to have come up, though. Many of us have been wheeled or gurneyed through the hospital skybridges you mention, of course, and some cities, including Minneapolis, Des Moines, and Calgary, have run with this idea, refashioning their downtowns into human-size Habitrails by linking buildings into a miles-long skyway network. These passages weren’t built as safety features, but rather for the convenience and comfort of shoppers and office workers in wintertime, and they’re typically only a couple stories above street level — not much help if you’re fleeing the 40th floor.

Skyways aren’t notably cheap — connecting a new football stadium to the existing Minneapolis system recently cost more than $10 million — and they’re out of favor with urbanists, who fret about foot traffic being diverted indoors, thus robbing city streets of their vibrancy. More to our point, they also might not be the safest structures in an emergency: for one thing, as Minneapolis discovered during a 1982 department-store fire, they channel smoke from a burning building to its neighbors all too effectively.

What, then, might replace a long trek downstairs? Hoping perhaps to capitalize on fears that official procedures are unreliable, canny entrepreneurs are now marketing individual emergency-response gear to potential evacuees. Reps for the SkySaver, an automatic rappelling backpack originally intended for urban-combat use, insist it could double as a “personal rescue device.” You clip your cable to something solid and climb out the window, and it slowly lowers you to the ground — as long as the ground isn’t more than 260 feet away, ’cause that’s how much cable you’ve got.

If jumping sounds better to you than dangling, the people selling the S.O.S. Parachute claim their product is safe to use from just 11 stories up, barely a hundred feet in the air. That’s close to the ground for even an experienced BASE jumper, and far lower than most paratroopers would be happy with. Remember too that city airspace can be both densely built and windy: one unexpected gust could slam you against a wall — or into your co-workers, should any of them have the same bright idea about chuting to safety.

Then again, you might instead consider the counterintuitive notion of heading up the stairs, at least if you work in certain cities: Los Angeles, say, where for decades all new skyscrapers had to be topped with helipads. (The requirement was scrapped two years ago.) If your building’s roof is unsuited for landing, heat, flames, and wind make a helicopter rescue tricky, and emergency personnel would rather avoid such a feat if possible. Safety experts in less copter-forward cities than L.A. advise against the roof option — heat rises, after all, and the top of a structure being consumed by flames is hardly a hospitable place to wait around on the off chance a helicopter might happen along.

But what if, despite all we’ve been told, elevators turn out to be the best way out of a burning building after all? That’s the theory behind occupant-evacuation elevators, designed to address the safety concerns that once made elevators the A-number-one way not to leave a building during a fire. In skyscrapers built on this principle, you’d evacuate by first taking the stairs to one of several sky-lobby floors — the ones where under non-emergency conditions passengers transfer from express to local elevators. (You might also get to the sky lobby via special shuttle elevators from designated “refuge floors” throughout the building.) The express car you eventually board contains drainage systems to prevent flooding and is protected from smoke by the pressurized shaft it travels through. The days of elevators returning to the ground floor and remaining disabled throughout a disaster may be numbered.

So let’s forget parachutes and copters and futuristic passageways zig-zagging across the skyline — building safety is one field where disruption, to use the loathsome tech jargon, matters less than incremental improvement. Engineers seem to have chosen to fine-tune older concepts rather than chase eye-popping new ones, and that makes sense: in case of fire, you want your evacuation to be as dull and uneventful as possible.

Related Posts with Thumbnails

Last Articles

reddit the ocho 100 percent oxygen advil drowsiness hidden vin locations pronounce veuve clicquot trivia etymology eskimo sex swim acronym crapulence definition real sacagawea does tin rust walmart bicycles mongoose dreamsicle vs creamsicle hulk pants double locking doors beef minute steak who killed rita boys tanning war chester shire waking up burping hanr block sandblast cast iron teardrop house snorting msg butane refill target shattered femur double malt scotch whaled on coke and aspirin sodium poisonous asleep blowjob mini moos ingredients propylene glycol alginate greta van susteren mouth how long do circuit breakers last does pure water boil what happened to greta's mouth weight limit on treadmills does macaroni go bad how long can pepperoni pizza sit out songs about lost love found again flight path to japan can you keep a crow as a pet cat teeth cleaning cost what did eric do to donna in bed virgin mint julep recipe learn to have sex who won the fight in rocky 1 where do turtles go in the winter time what is the pocket in underwear for what does a jail cell look like lex luthor vs dr doom classical pipe organ music how many lakes are there in minnesota jury duty as a college student sears microwave installation cost why is japanese porn so weird what causes orange peel in clear coat oil tank pump out absentee ballots not counted unless close log base 2 matlab where did the term hot mess come from do morning glory seeds make you trip toilet tank bolts rusted why does taco bell cause diarrhea buy car direct from factory how to find a business that no longer exists do pigs have split hooves anatomy of female dog did indians have facial hair

Recent Additions:

A Straight Dope Staff Report by SDStaff Ken,
A Straight Dope Classic by Cecil Adams
A Straight Dope Staff Report by SDStaff Doug, Straight Dope Science Advisory Board
A Straight Dope Classic by Cecil Adams
A Straight Dope Staff Report by SDStaff Chronos, Straight Dope Science Advisory Board
A Straight Dope Classic by Cecil Adams
A Straight Dope Staff Report by SDStaff Doug, Straight Dope Science Advisory Board
A Straight Dope Classic by Cecil Adams
A Straight Dope Staff Report by SDStaff ScottInLA, Straight Dope Science Advisory Board
A Straight Dope Staff Report by SDStaff Jillgat, Straight Dope Science Advisory Board